Quotes

The Gist

The Gist is Chih-i’s third classification of the Five Sections in interpreting the Lotus Sūtra. Having presented his system of understanding Buddhism in the first section “name,” and having sustained his system by presenting the Ultimate Truth as the substance in the second section “substance,” in this section “gist” what Chih-i aims at revealing is the essential teaching of the Buddha in terms of the cause and effect of Buddhahood, because gist is interrelated with the substance: with the substance, gist is sustained; and with the gist, substance is manifested. (Vol. 2, Page 439)

The Profound Meaning of the Lotus Sutra: Tien-tai Philosophy of Buddhism


Predictions of Our Own Enlightenment

As practitioners of Buddhism the predictions presented in the [Lotus Sutra] offer us unlimited hope of our own enlightenment. We have, if we choose, the foundation on which to base very hopeful future stories regardless of the struggles facing us in this moment. If we had no promise of enlightenment, then practicing Buddhism would be a sketchy proposition at best and possibly a dismal future at worst. Without the promise of enlightenment then what would we have on which to base our future?

Lecture on the Lotus Sutra

Conceptions of an Afterlife

It is important to note that Nichiren’s aspiration for achieving the Pure Land of Eagle Peak after death never replaced his conviction that, by the spread of exclusive faith in the Lotus and in accordance with the principle of risshō ankoku, the pure land could be realized in the present world. It also coexists in his thought with his teaching that enlightenment is manifested in the moment of faith and chanting. In other traditions as well, notions of directly accessible or even immanent Buddhahood did not rule out conceptions of an afterlife in a different realm but often existed alongside them: “Even though one knows Amida Buddha to be one’s own mind, one forms a relationship with Amida of the west.” However, unlike some strands of Pure Land thought directed toward Amida, Nichiren’s “Pure Land of Sacred Eagle Peak” lacks a sense of concreteness as an actual place postulated over and against the present world; it is never said to lie in a specific direction, nor does aspiring toward it involve repudiating the present world. In the few passages of Nichiren’s writings where some sort of description is offered, it is usually along the lines of “[M]aster and disciples shall together visit the Pure Land of Sacred [Eagle] Peak and behold the faces of the three Buddhas [Śākyamuni, Many-Jewels, and all the Buddhas who are Śākyamuni’s emanations],” or “If one inquires where the late Abutsu-bō is now, he is within the jeweled stūpa of the Buddha Many-Jewels on Sacred Eagle Peak.” In short, this pure land resembles the assembly in open space depicted on Nichiren’s mandala and may be thought of as an extension of that realm to encompass the faithful dead. (Page 294)

Original Enlightenment and the Transformation of Medieval Japanese Buddhism


The All-Embracing Nature of the Ultimate Truth

Whereas the Ultimate Truth is proved to be the substance of the Lotus Sūtra, upon which all the coarse dharmas can be converged into the subtle dharma, Chih-i further argues that the Ultimate Truth can also be taken as the universal substance for all sūtras, based on his own theory of the all-embracing nature of the Ultimate Truth.

In the first aspect, Chih-i argues that the Ultimate Truth as the substance of the Lotus Sūtra actually bears different names, which are indicated in various quotations cited. The phrases quoted by Chih-i, such as “presently, the Buddha signals rays of light, wishing to reveal the doctrine of the Ultimate Truth,” “the doctrine of the Ultimate Truth of all dharmas, I have already taught you,” “to open the Buddha’s insight and knowledge,” “unsurpassed Path,” and so on, support his argument that these names refer to the Ultimate Truth. (Vol. 2, Page 429-430)

The Profound Meaning of the Lotus Sutra: Tien-tai Philosophy of Buddhism


Defilements

Before looking at the non-dual nature of defilements and awakening, we should make sure that we clearly understand what is meant by the two terms. Defilements are those personal characteristics or personality traits that keep us in a state of agitation, anxiety, or frustration and prevent us from realizing our own Buddha-nature. “Defilements” refers to the Three Poisons of greed, hatred, and delusion, and also to pride, false views, and doubt. According to Buddhism, the neediness of greed, the paranoia of hatred, the confusion of delusion, and the negativity generated by the other defilements are what keep us from feeling totally at ease, happy, peaceful, and confident. Because of these defilements, we never see things in the true light of reality. …

On the other hand, the defilements, or self-centered desires, can also be viewed as positive qualities that have not yet developed. For instance, those who are full of craving and attachment are also capable of single-minded devotion to the Three Treasures. Those who are highly critical and hostile towards others also have the capacity to develop critical thinking in order to discern truth from falsehood. Those whose minds are easily distracted by endless speculation are also acknowledged for their open-mindedness and curiosity. Buddhism recognizes that ignorant desires can be harnessed or developed into good qualities. We should also keep in mind that these defilements are the very qualities which motivate us to practice Buddhism. After all, if our lives were perfect and we felt neither desire nor dissatisfaction, then there would be no need to seek out the true nature of all existence or to cultivate the wisdom and compassion of Buddhahood. Our recognition of these qualities as defilements reveals a deep need within us to find meaning, security, and true happiness.

Lotus Seeds

Aspiration for the Pure Land of Eagle Peak

In Nichiren’s thought, aspiration for the Pure Land of Eagle Peak assumes a particular orientation, informed by his exclusive commitment to the Lotus Sūtra. Most Lotus practitioners of the Heian and Kamakura periods recited the sūtra in hopes of achieving Amida’s western Pure Land. Nichiren, however, had so thoroughly rejected any aspect of faith in Amida that he would not have been able to represent the next life in such terms. The “Pure Land of Sacred Eagle Peak” provided him with a needed alternative image, consistent with his Lotus exclusivism, for conceptualizing what happens to believers after death. As others have suggested, Nichiren may also have begun to preach to his followers about this pure land in response to the sense of imminent danger accompanying the Mongol threat, and the concept was no doubt further stimulated by the suppressions experienced by Nichiren and his community. The “Pure Land of Eagle Peak” was thus posited in contrast to, and as recompense for enduring, the hardships occasioned by upholding exclusive faith in the Lotus in this present world. Moreover, during his reclusion on Mt. Minobu, as Nichiren himself grew older, he was also faced increasingly with the need to console followers who had lost parents, spouses, and children; the promise of reunion in the Pure Land of Eagle Peak occurs frequently in his letters on such occasions. (Page 293-294)

Original Enlightenment and the Transformation of Medieval Japanese Buddhism


The Ultimate Truth as Substance Is Same

Chih-i reiterates that although there are different teachings in accordance with different abilities of beings, the Ultimate Truth as substance is the same. He explains that the Buddha teaches four different Dharma-doors in accordance with four kinds of faculties of beings. Different teachings of the Buddha designate names different. Separate functions of the teaching designate meanings also different. However, as one’s final realization of the principle is not different, the underlying substance is the same. (Vol. 2, Page 416)

The Profound Meaning of the Lotus Sutra: Tien-tai Philosophy of Buddhism


The Pure Land of Sacred Eagle Peak

THE PURE LAND OF SACRED EAGLE PEAK

Shortly before his exile to Sado, Nichiren began to refer in his letters and other writings to the “Pure land of Sacred [Eagle] Peak” (ryōzen jōdo). These references increase during the Sado period and especially during Nichiren’s retirement on Mt. Minobu. “Sacred Eagle Peak” (or “Sacred Vulture Peak”) translates Ryōjusen (Chn. Ling-chiu-shan), the Chinese translation for Gṛdhrakūṭa (Vulture Peak), the name of the mountain in Rājagṛha where the Lotus Sūtra is said to have been preached. The notion of Eagle Peak as a pure land seems to arise from a conflation of this site with the sūtra’s assertion that this Sahā world is the eternal dwelling place of the original Buddha:

Throughout asaṃkhya-kalpas I am always on Sacred Eagle Peak as well as in other dwelling places. When the beings see the kalpa ending and [the world] being consumed in a great fire, this land of mine is safe and peaceful, always filled with gods and humans.

In it are gardens, groves, halls, and towers . . . wherein the beings play and amuse themselves . . . My pure land is not destroyed, yet the multitude see it consumed in flames.

Worried, they fear the torment of pains. … Those who have cultivated merit, who are gentle and agreeable, straightforward and honest, all do, however, see my body dwelling here and preaching the Dharma.

Kumārajīva (344—413), the sūtra’s translator, is said to have interpreted the lines “My pure land is not destroyed / yet the multitude see it consumed in flames” to mean “the two qualities of purity and defilement dwelling in the same place.” Since his time, “Eagle Peak” was frequently understood as representing the ontological nonduality of delusion and enlightenment, or of the present, Sahā world and the Land of Ever Tranquil Light. This reading clearly informs Nichiren’s understanding of the present world as potentially the Buddha land… . However, “Sacred Eagle Peak” was also known to be a specific place and, in the manner of many continental sacred sites, had manifested itself in Japan. Mt. Hiei, Ōmine, Kasagi, and other locations of mountain ascetic practice were all at times identified with “Eagle Peak.” Nichiren, too, occasionally equated Eagle Peak with Mt. Minobu, where he, the gyōja of the Lotus Sūtra, was living. (Page 292-293)

Original Enlightenment and the Transformation of Medieval Japanese Buddhism


Greater Vehicle

Chih-i concludes that [his three analogies concerning Ultimate Truth as substance] embody the subtleties of substance, function, and gist. The substance of the Lotus Sūtra as the Ultimate Truth is like the big elephant touching the bottom of mud, so firm that this substance cannot be destroyed. This analogizes the Subtlety of Substance (T’i-miao). The wishing-grant gem Ju-i that rains down treasures analogizes the Subtlety of Function (Yung-miao). The skilled wisdom of the bodhisattva of the Perfect Teaching analogizes the Subtlety of Gist (Tsung-miao). Chih-i adds that these three subtleties that cannot be conceptualized as either vertical or horizontal are named “Greater Vehicle.” (Vol. 2, Page 412)

The Profound Meaning of the Lotus Sutra: Tien-tai Philosophy of Buddhism


Right Meditation

Right views, right thought, right speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, and right mindfulness all serve to make right meditation easier. Conversely, right meditation promotes the smooth practice of all the other steps.
Basic Buddhist Concepts